The Guard of Honor
The Guard of Honor is the highest award the Fraternity can bestow upon a member, is a guard pin with a Tudor rose in gold, with a sapphire center.
The Senior Service Award
The Senior Service Award is a guard pin formally described as follows: a black enameled open book with a Tudor rose on the left half and with double cross-crosslet on the right. The Senior Service Award is given annually by a chapter at its Founders' Day observance to a collegiate senior whose scholarship, leadership, character, and service to fraternity and school have been outstanding.
The Siena Medal
The Siena Medal is a round gold medal bearing the coat of arms of Theta Phi Alpha and inscribed in Greek with the Theta Phi Alpha Motto: "Nothing great is ever achieved without much enduring." The medal is named for St. Catherine of Siena, the patroness of Theta Phi Alpha.